YOUR FEEDBACK
Three RIA Platforms Compared: Adobe Flex, Google Web Toolkit, and OpenLaszlo
NN wrote: Yeah you are right GWT is poor man's Flex. After using GWT on two...
SOA World Conference
Virtualization Conference
$200 Savings Expire May 16, 2008... – Register Today!

SYS-CON.TV
TOP LINKS YOU MUST CLICK ON


Viewpoint: Is Google Growing Too Fast?
Is Google growing too fast to continue producing innovative software while maintaining the quality that's become expected of it?

Digg This!

Neil Smithline's Blog

Is Google growing too fast to continue to produce innovative software while maintaining the quality that has become expected of it? I've had some problems with their alerts and sent in comments and, excluding the automated email replies, have received no response nor has the problem been corrected.

In general I would have to say I'm a fan of Google. I think that they have reached their current status through hard work and clever thinking from the top executives, to the coding monkeys, to the system administrators. Despite having had some problems with them, my most recent posting regarding them was commenting on their ingenuity.

But I've had some problems with their alerts and sent in comments and, excluding the automated email replies, have received no response nor has the problem been corrected.

Being that I have a relative uncommon last name, I actually have an alert for "smithline". When a match is found it is almost always me or one of my family members. Probably not a very useful trick for someone named "John Smith" but it is helpful for me. When it Google finds a new web page match, it sends me an email that looks very similar to a search results page but it just contains the new matches. For example:

Google Web Alert for: smithline

The Mathematics Genealogy Project - Lawren Smithline
Lawren Michael Smithline. Ph.D. University of California, Berkeley 2000 UnitedStates. Dissertation: Slopes of p-Adic Modular Forms ...

Notice that the title tells you what is being searched for (“smithline”), the title of the page that had a match, and an excerpt of the page with the matched string (“smithline”) highlighted. If you are at all familiar to the results of a Google search, (if not what cave have you been in) then this should all seem familiar.

But for the past 6-8 weeks there have been some problems. I contacted Google the 2nd time the the problem occurred. Here is one example of it:

Google News Alert for: smithline

What's behind the sudden poll shift?
Spectator.co.uk (subscription) - UK
Even more deluded was the Smith line that the polls actually reflected his and Labour's popularity. We pointed out that this was nonsense - the polls were ...
See all stories on this topic

You'll notice that “smithline” does not actually appear in the selection (or in the rest of the article if you search). It is some political article referring to the stance taken by a Mr. Smith and is referring to it as the "Smith line". Even wo rse, I received this:

Google News Alert for: smithline

Two hurt in two-car crash on Selwyn Road
Peterborough Examiner - Peterborough,Ontario,Canada
Two people were taken to hospital Thursday after a collision north of the city at Selwyn Road and the 11th Line of Smith, between Bridgenorth and Lakefield. ...
See all stories on this topic

This has both the words “smith” and “line” but they are not next to each other and not even in order. At least they are close to each other in “Line of Smith”. Also, notice that nothing is highlighted. Even the highlighting engine of Google could not figure out what substring the search engine had matched on. But, saving the worst for last,
Google News Alert for: smithline

Family of former coach files suit
Pittsburg Morning Sun - Pittsburg,KS,USA
By Matthew Clark | THE MORNING SUN GIRARD — The family of former Girard High School head football coach Craig Crespino has levied a negligence lawsuit ...
See all stories on this topic

Notice that this excerpt has neither a “smith” nor "“line”. If you go to the article, it does have those words in them but they are not even close to each other as they were in the “Line of Smith”.

Besides these problems, I'm having a terrible problem with another search. One of my children has a chronic condition (minor but annoying - details withheld for privacy reasons). So I have a search for the word “adolescent” and the name of the chronic condition. This search is wholly useless. I've included two of the nine hits I received - the rest were basically the same. I have modified the search results for privacy, removed URLs to the sites to prevent this being an advertisement for them, and removed obscenities for my more genteel readers..

Google Groups Alert for: "redacted for privacy" adolescent

Union obscenity deleted
... serpientes sexo gratis spokane washington gay scene nutritional facts for smoked
turkey breast adolescent sexuality arti amish sex vid tenacious d, sex tnt obscenity deleted pet hardcore sex bible books job and sexual molestation federal uniform manifest system escorts gay male.louisiana dog has sex ...
removed to avoid advertisement - Mar 21, 2008 by - 0 message - 0 author

Registry Sex Offender
... slaves n the us racquet club hilton head lady gemini dream transition from
adolescent to adult china rape fantasy free sian resort hollywood florida job
...redacted for privacy ...
removed to avoid advertisement - Mar 21, 2008 by - 0 message - 0 author

Hard to imagine how this is useful...

I'm beginning to wonder if Google is growing too fast to continue to produce innovative software while maintaining the quality that has become expected of them.

About Neil Smithline
Neil Smithline has been working with software for 25+ years. From his first paying job of coding on a TRS-80 to his current role of application security specialist at BEA Systems, Neil has worked on many aspects of computer systems ranging from small applications to enterprise systems in use by millions of users. He entertains himself (and hopefully a few other people) by writing whatever technology-centric ideas come to his mind on www.smithline.net. When he is not wasting his time on computers he is a father of two, husband, and son.

Worrying Trends wrote: Google won;t index this story, just watch. That's the REALLY scary thing!!!!
read & respond »
LATEST SEO/SEM STORIES
Powerset Seeks to Change the Way Users Search and Consume Web Content
'Wikipedia is a great way for us to showcase Powerset's functionality while giving people a faster time to satisfaction,' said Barney Pell, co-founder and CTO of Powerset, as his company today unveiled a publicly available beta product that according to Pell reinvents how users search
Enterprise Web Security Added to Google Apps
Google has taken its Postini investment and turned out Google Web Security for the Enterprise, which is supposed to protect against spyware, viruses and zero-hour threats in real-time whether the user is on the corporate network or working remotely like at a hotel or in an airport. If
Microsoft, Unisys, Yahoo and Vista
Microsoft, which spent $6 billion on aQuantive and was chasing Yahoo for its ads before it came to a dead stop, has been supporting - as in helping write - legislation in New York and Connecticut that would regulate the data that companies like Yahoo and Google collect for targeted adv
Yahoo! How Like the Virgin Mary!
So how does it feel to have witnessed one of technology's little miracles this week? I mean Yahoo's stock price successfully defying gravity. It's as close as any of us will ever get to an apparition of the Virgin Mary floating on a cloud without any visible means of support. Apparentl
Yahoo Pays the Piper
Yahoo's stock dropped roughly 19%-20% this morning at the open, shaving $8.7 billion off its value, its first installment on the price of its independence from Microsoft. Yahoo, whose position improved a couple of percentage points in the first half-hour of trading, is being held up by
Microsoft Will End Up Buying Yahoo Anyway
Yahoo! founders Jerry Yang and David Filo received stupid advice from their investment bank advisers and blew their chance to close the deal with Microsoft as of this Sunday morning. Neither Yang nor Filo are experts on how to sell a company in a multi-billion dollar deal. They have re
SUBSCRIBE TO THE WORLD'S MOST POWERFUL NEWSLETTERS
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR RSS FEEDS & GET YOUR SYS-CON NEWS LIVE!
Click to Add our RSS Feeds to the Service of Your Choice:
Google Reader or Homepage Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online
myFeedster Add to My AOL Subscribe in Rojo Add 'Hugg' to Newsburst from CNET News.com Kinja Digest View Additional SYS-CON Feeds
Publish Your Article! Please send it to editorial(at)sys-con.com!

Advertise on this site! Contact advertising(at)sys-con.com! 201 802-3021

SYS-CON FEATURED WHITEPAPERS

ADS BY GOOGLE