| By Maureen O'Gara | Article Rating: |
|
| January 11, 2013 08:00 AM EST | Reads: |
2,380 |
Following the consent decree Google signed last week with the Federal Trade Commission limiting its use of standards-essential patents (SEPs), Google satellite Motorola Mobility told the International Trade Commission Tuesday it wants to drop the two remaining video compression SEP claims it's been pushing against Microsoft.
Motorola has already abandoned other SEP claims in the suit.
Microsoft wants to license the H.264 IP for its Xbox gaming console but only on fair and reasonable terms and has rejected Google's demand for billions of dollars a year.

For its part Google wants to block Xbox imports into the US but the FTC told Google it had to license the widgetry to "willing licensees" even if that takes binding arbitration.
Motorola Mobility still wants to pursue Microsoft on a non-SEP infringement charge and wants damages on all the patents. Such a scenario would take an appeal to the Federal Circuit.
Google is also still involved in suits over SEP injunctions in federal court in Seattle and in Germany.
Microsoft anticipated Motorola's dismissal move in a filing Monday.
Motorola is taking evidently the same tack with Apple. In the Apple case it needs the ITC to reverse Administrative Judge Thomas Pender's finding that the non-SEP patent it wants to use to cripple Apple is invalid although Apple appears to tread on it. It concerns deactivating a touchscreen when the phone is held close to the user's ear during a call. Apple may be able to rebuff the charge. It's hard to tell since the motions are sealed.
Then on Tuesday the Justice Department and the Patent and Trademark Office put out an unusual position paper on the SEP remedies that FOSS Patents says "muddies the water" and becomes "part of the problem."
The blog takes issue with the agencies' statement that "if a putative licensee refuses to pay what has been determined to be a F/RAND royalty, or refuses to engage in a negotiation to determine F/RAND terms, an exclusion order could be appropriate. Such a refusal could take the form of a constructive refusal to negotiate, such as by insisting on terms clearly outside the bounds of what could reasonably be considered to be F/RAND terms in an attempt to evade the putative licensee's obligation to fairly compensate the patent holder. This list is not an exhaustive one."
It says the loophole is "totally open-ended" citing the policy statement's unbounded position on this so-called "constructive refusal to negotiate" as grounds for an injunction for SEP infringement.
It figures that the agencies' saying the list is "not exhaustive" means the DOJ and the PTO "aren't serious about curbing SEP abuse." They want to keep the door open to SEP-based injunctions whereas the FTC should realize that "the notion of mutually assured SEP-based destruction" is a bad idea that no one other than Google and its minions would want to support.
Published January 11, 2013 Reads 2,380
Copyright © 2013 SYS-CON Media, Inc. — All Rights Reserved.
Syndicated stories and blog feeds, all rights reserved by the author.
More Stories By Maureen O'Gara
Maureen O'Gara the most read technology reporter for the past 20 years, is the Cloud Computing and Virtualization News Desk editor of SYS-CON Media. She is the publisher of famous "Billygrams" and the editor-in-chief of "Client/Server News" for more than a decade. One of the most respected technology reporters in the business, Maureen can be reached by email at maureen(at)sys-con.com or paperboy(at)g2news.com, and by phone at 516 759-7025. Twitter: @MaureenOGara
- Cloud People: A Who's Who of Cloud Computing
- Enterasys Spotlights SDN's Impact on Traditional Networking in Upcoming Webinar
- NASA's Twitter Account Wins Back-To-Back Shorty Awards
- Google Compute enters the IaaS market
- GoBank Announces Timing of General Availability and National Distribution Relationships at FinovateSpring
- MicroStrategy Announces General Availability of MicroStrategy 9.3.1
- MicroStrategy Announces General Availability of MicroStrategy 9.3.1
- Cloud Expo | Maximizing the Small Things: Efficiencies for Cloud Hardware
- Cloud Business Solutions, Social Media, and Platform Systems of Engagement Market Shares, Strategies, and Forecasts, Worldwide, 2013 to 2019
- Google Submits Concessions to EC; Gets Sued in the UK
- Infinity Augmented Reality and Technical Evangelist Robert Scoble Are Enthusiastic About the Upcoming Release of Google Glass
- Global Mobile Security (mSecurity) Market 2013-2018
- Cloud People: A Who's Who of Cloud Computing
- Enterasys Spotlights SDN's Impact on Traditional Networking in Upcoming Webinar
- RetailMeNot Shoppers Trend Report: While Over 8 in 10 U.S. Residents Cite Affordability as Their Top Vacation Priority, a Majority (58%) Could Waste Hundreds of Dollars by Booking Travel a la Carte
- NASA's Twitter Account Wins Back-To-Back Shorty Awards
- ChannelAdvisor Participates in Upcoming Retail Industry Conferences RBTE and Retail Week Live
- Basho Announces Open Source Riak CS and General Availability of Riak CS Enterprise v1.3
- Google Compute enters the IaaS market
- How to Protect Your Facebook Account Before Graph Search is Public
- Google Says Motorola’s Upcoming Phones Don’t ‘Wow’ Them
- Why Cloud Computing Skills Will Be Required for IT Workers
- GoBank Announces Timing of General Availability and National Distribution Relationships at FinovateSpring
- MicroStrategy Announces General Availability of MicroStrategy 9.3.1
- Where Are RIA Technologies Headed in 2008?
- Cloud People: A Who's Who of Cloud Computing
- Dolphin Announces Open API With Over 50 Add-ons Including Dropbox and Wikipedia
- ManageWP Powers Over 100,000 WordPress Sites Within Three Months of Launch
- SEO/SEM Tips & Tricks: How and When Should You Submit Your Website to Google?
- Google Version 2.0: Googzilla - The Calculating Predator
- Google's Competitive Advantage: It Leverages "The Power of Free"
- Cloud Expo 2011 East To Attract 10,000 Delegates and 200 Exhibitors
- Google Space Launches at Heathrow Airport
- AOL To Enhance Video Search Engine by Adding RSS Feeds
- Ulitzer’s Amazing First 30 Days in Public Beta
- The World's Youngest "Google Entrepreneur" Is One Month Old



























